Six Eaglet Hockey teams have qualified for the Academic All-State Team Award by the MHSHCA: 2002-03, 2003-04, 2004-05, 2005-06, 2006-07, and 2009-10. In addition, four times a senior Eaglet was named Academic All-State Player of the Year: Kyle Miller (2004), Jonathan Castine (2006), Anthony Aukskalnis (2007), and Jordan Kieltyka (2009).
Sixteen senior Eaglets have been named Academic All-State: (2010) Kevin Killian, Alex Zerbo, Luke Guminik, Ian Brambs; (2009) Maxwell Borchers, Andrew Cloonan, Maxwell Oslund, Matthew Uhrin; (2006) Jeffrey Mydlowski, Shane Dwyer, Alex Prough, Jonathan Connors; (2005) Shane Trexler; (2000) Mario Martinez; (1998) Andrew Soltes, Jerad Wolfrum.
Two Eaglets have been named Dream Team by the MHSHCA: Patrick Nagorsen (2004) and Shane Trexler (2005).
Twenty-two Eaglets have been named First Team All-State, two named Second Team All-State, and eight named Honorable Mention All-State by the MHSHCA.
Four Eaglet alumni are currently or have played professional hockey: Jason Basile – Bossier Shreveport; Artur Kret – Polish Pro League; Marciej Sulka – Polish Pro League; Krystian Dziubinski – Polish Pro League.
Thirty-three Eaglet alumni are currently or have played Junior “A” or Junior “B” hockey.
Nineteen Eaglet alumni are currently or have played college hockey at the Division I, II or III level, while twelve Eaglet alumni are currently or have played college hockey at the club level.